Croydon man convicted of murdering partner Sarah Reynolds
Earlston Bennett, 58, was convicted at Southwark Crown Court on 6 October 2026 of murdering his long-term partner, Sarah Reynolds, and of controlling or coercive behaviour in an intimate relationship.
At 04:36hrs on 12 April 2025, Bennett called 999 and reported that Sarah had taken an overdose of prescription medication and was unresponsive.
The London Ambulance Service arrived within minutes and began resuscitation attempts. Sarah was taken to hospital where, despite the efforts of paramedics and clinicians, she was pronounced dead shortly before 06:00hrs.
A paramedic who was first on the scene had noticed injuries to the victim’s body and questioned Bennett about them. He admitted they had argued earlier in the evening, but maintained that his partner had suffered an overdose.
A post-mortem examination subsequently found she had suffered significant injuries and had died as a result of blunt force trauma to her torso and head.
Bennett was arrested for causing grievous bodily harm at 05:05hrs, while paramedics were still attempting to save his partner’s life. As he was taken to the police station, he was overheard complaining about Sarah, asking: “How could you do this to me.”
He was re-arrested on suspicion of murder shortly after 06:00hrs. In interview, he admitted physically assaulting his partner earlier that evening but denied killing her. He subsequently sought to suggest that her injuries and death were a result of drugs overdose, falls and CPR administered by medics.
A post-mortem found that Reynolds died from blunt-force injuries to her head and torso. Prosecutors also presented messages and other evidence of Bennett’s controlling and abusive conduct. Sentencing is scheduled for 4 December 2026.
You must be logged in to post a comment.