In 2021, Esha Proudlove, 20, and Craig Shingler, 24, of Ellesmere Port, appeared at Wirral Magistrates’ Court over the treatment of two dogs, Maya and Milo.
Prosecutor Peter Mitchell said neighbours at Proudlove’s previous flat in Neston reported hearing arguments, dogs yelping and what they believed to be repeated blows. One neighbour also saw a urine-soaked carpet left in a communal hallway.
Proudlove acquired Maya, a brindle crossbreed, in October 2020. A vet examined her for head trauma on 16 October after being told she had fallen from a sofa. A bleed was found in her right eye the next morning.
Two days later Proudlove claimed she had performed CPR, but the vet found no evidence of it. On 12 November Maya returned with chest swelling consistent with severe force or strangulation.
She was brought back later that day with three fractured ribs. Proudlove blamed those injuries on the puppy squeezing out of a crate.
An expert reported significant violence and evidence of two episodes of severe head trauma.
Proudlove admitted two counts of causing unnecessary suffering to Maya and a welfare offence involving Milo. Shingler admitted causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal and failing to take reasonable steps to meet Milo’s needs. Magistrates said Shingler had failed to intervene and took account of Proudlove’s treatment needs, previous good character and prospects of rehabilitation.
Proudlove received 12 weeks in prison suspended for one year, alongside 20 rehabilitation activity requirements, an eight-week overnight curfew, £250 costs and a £128 surcharge. Shingler reportedly received ten weeks suspended for one year, ten rehabilitation activity requirements and 150 hours of unpaid work. Maya was rehomed.
You must be logged in to post a comment.